What toys do your cats love? We have three cats and they all have different things they like. For instance one of our cats will not play with toys from the store although he will play with random things he finds around the house.\n \nOur other cats will play with the little balls with the bell inside of them. And our third cat loves pens. Go figure, the one thing hard to keep around in the house and he has to take them to play with them. We generally do a hunt for them and find a stash under the couch.\n \nOne also like toilet paper! What a mess he makes!